
Electric Vehicle Life-Cycle Emissions and Electricity Sources
By: Dr. Eka Rakhman Priandana (KOLEKSI 900)
InfrastructureIntroduction: Electric Vehicles Do Not Mean Zero Emissions
Electric vehicles (EVs) produce no tailpipe emissions while being driven. However, describing them as “zero-emission” without specifying the assessment boundary can be misleading. The electricity used to charge their batteries must be generated, the vehicles and their batteries must be manufactured, and all components must ultimately be managed at the end of their service lives. A fair comparison therefore uses a life-cycle assessment (LCA), which accounts for greenhouse gas emissions from raw-material extraction through vehicle use and end-of-life management. The key question is not simply whether a vehicle runs on gasoline or electricity, but also how clean the electricity it uses is.
From Production to End of Life
Manufacturing EVs can generate relatively high upfront emissions, particularly from mineral processing, active-material production, and battery manufacturing. The impact varies depending on battery chemistry, battery capacity, manufacturing location, electricity source, and process efficiency. It is therefore inappropriate to assign a single production-emissions figure to all batteries. The International Energy Agency (IEA) shows that the main sources of emissions across the supply chain also differ between nickel manganese cobalt (NMC) and lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries. Reducing emissions from factory electricity use, improving process efficiency, and using recycled materials are just as important as choosing the battery chemistry. [5][6]
During the use phase, EVs do not burn gasoline, but their electricity consumption still entails emissions in line with the carbon intensity of the power system. At end of life, battery reuse (second-life applications) and recycling can help make use of the remaining capacity and reduce demand for primary raw materials. However, the net benefit depends on material recovery rates, the energy consumed by the process, safety, and the governance of battery collection. In other words, EVs incur part of their “emissions debt” upfront, with the potential to offset it through lower operational emissions.
Electricity Sources Determine the Outcome
A simple estimate of an EV’s operational emissions can be expressed as follows:
EV electricity-related emissions per kilometer = vehicle electricity consumption (kWh/km) × electricity emissions intensity (kg CO₂e/kWh).
To estimate life-cycle emissions, this figure must be supplemented by emissions from vehicle and battery manufacturing, maintenance, and end-of-life management. Comparisons with gasoline vehicles must also include the extraction, processing, and distribution of fuel. EVs are generally more energy-efficient at converting energy into motion than internal combustion engines. This efficiency advantage helps reduce emissions, but the magnitude of the reduction still depends on the generation mix and the characteristics of the vehicles being compared. [1][4]
In power systems heavily dependent on coal, emissions associated with charging will be higher than in systems supplied by hydropower, solar, wind, or other low-carbon sources. Charging time can also matter, but this does not automatically mean that charging at 10 a.m. is always cleaner than charging at 7 p.m. Such a conclusion requires generation and load data for the relevant periods, including whether solar generation is in surplus or fossil-fuel power plants are still supplying the additional load. Smart charging is most beneficial when it can shift loads to periods when low-carbon electricity is actually available.
What Do the Data Say About Indonesia?
An ICCT study by Mera and Bieker, which modeled vehicles sold in Indonesia in 2023, found that battery electric vehicles (BEVs) have life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions approximately 47–56% lower than those of comparable gasoline cars. For A-segment cars, estimated emissions are 108–127 grams of CO₂-equivalent per kilometer for BEVs, compared with 246 grams for gasoline cars. For SUVs, the range is 145–167 grams, compared with 316 grams; for MPVs, it is 194–224 grams, compared with 420 grams. The BEV ranges reflect different electricity-mix development scenarios, rather than direct measurements for every vehicle on the road. [1]
A more recent ICCT study also estimates that electric scooters can already reduce life-cycle emissions by approximately 27% compared with gasoline-powered scooters under the 2023 modeling assumptions. This reduction could increase by 2030 if the power system moves toward a net-zero scenario. [7] These findings are important for Indonesia because the benefits of electrification are not limited to passenger cars; they can also extend to motorcycles used for everyday mobility.
Official data illustrate why power-sector decarbonization must go hand in hand with transport electrification. The 2024 Electricity Statistics Book published by the Directorate General of Electricity records that, in PLN’s primary energy mix for power generation in 2024, coal accounted for 66.43%, natural gas for 17.65%, and oil fuels/biofuels for 3.93%; the remainder came mainly from hydropower, geothermal energy, biomass, and other renewable sources. For 2025, the Directorate General of New, Renewable Energy and Energy Conservation reported that renewable energy accounted for 16.25% of the electricity sector’s energy mix. These figures refer to different indicators and reporting years and should therefore not be combined into a single statistical series. Nevertheless, both indicate that fossil-fuel power generation continues to play a major role. [2][3]
Through PLN’s 2025–2034 Electricity Supply Business Plan (RUPTL), the Government plans to add 69.5 GW of power generation capacity, with approximately 76% allocated to renewable energy and energy storage systems. This is a target for the composition of additional capacity; it does not mean that 76% of the electricity currently consumed comes from renewable sources. The actual deployment of generation capacity, transmission networks, system flexibility, and energy storage will determine how quickly this plan reduces the carbon intensity of electricity. [4]
Correcting Misconceptions and Shaping Policy
The claim that EVs merely “shift pollution to coal-fired power plants” overlooks two points. First, life-cycle emissions already include emissions from electricity generation; the Indonesia study cited above still finds that BEVs have lower emissions than gasoline cars. Second, pollutants from power plants are point-source emissions that can be monitored and controlled. However, this does not eliminate coal’s impacts on the climate or air quality. Emissions controls at coal-fired power plants and reductions in coal use remain necessary.
The opposite misconception must also be avoided: EVs are not automatically free of environmental impacts. Mineral extraction, battery manufacturing, and the management of used batteries must meet environmental and social standards. Therefore, EV incentives should be designed alongside policies that accelerate renewable energy deployment, promote low-carbon battery manufacturing, improve battery collection and recycling systems, and develop smart charging. Rooftop solar PV installations integrated with EV charging can reduce emissions associated with the electricity consumed, provided that the timing of solar generation is aligned with charging demand.
Conclusion
EVs today are not entirely emissions-free, but modeling evidence for Indonesia indicates that BEVs can have substantially lower life-cycle emissions than gasoline-powered vehicles. The scale of this benefit is not fixed: it depends on vehicle size and efficiency, battery production, service life, and, above all, the carbon intensity of electricity during vehicle operation. The transition to electric mobility and the transition of the power sector must therefore be treated as a single agenda. EVs are not a perfect solution, but an important advantage is that their operational emissions can continue to decline as the electricity they use becomes cleaner.
Related Articles

9 Nov 2026
REVIEW OF THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK BATTERY-BASED ELECTRIC MOTOR VEHICLES IN INDONESIA
By: Arwani Hidayat (KOLEKSI 1)

27 Oct 2026
AVAILABILITY OF ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE AND STANDARDS IN INDONESIA
By: Dr. Eka Rakhman Priandana (KOLEKSI 900)

27 Oct 2026
AS CHINA SHAKES UP THE LFP-BASED EV BATTERY MARKET: IS INDONESIAN NICKEL STILL THE PRIMADONNA?
By: Bagus Anggraini, M.T. (KOLEKSI 9001)